SEAWIND R/C MODEL
YACHT: Proposed One-Design Class Above Deck
Changes
By: Mike Eades,
Seawind US 089
In part 1 of
these notes I expressed the view that the Seawind kit has
some shortcomings. This note amplifies this view,
summarizes some of the attempted improvements and offers
some thoughts on where the draft Class rules might
accommodate some improvements.
Attached to this
note are some photographs labeled Seawind Detail (SD1-5), which I will refer to as I go
along.
1.
Rigging Materials The line supplied with the kit
is terrible, stiff with a strong memory where bent
sharply. The adjustment bowsies are too small and fiddly
especially for semi-arthritic fingers! Seems like
many others feel this way. I now use plastic coated
fishing leader wire for shrouds, forestay and backstay (SD1). To allow adjustment to
the fore and backstays I use a length of Spectra 2000 ES
55 200# line with home made bowsies (from the cut off
pieces from the servo horn). I use brass swivels with
attached safety pins to attach the ends of the forestay
to the jib club and mast (SD4 & 5). The shrouds are
attached and adjusted using a Dubro clevis with screw and
locking nut (SD3). For running rigging I
use Spectra 2000 ES 55, 200# or 50# as noted below.
Suppliers:
Steelon plastic coated wire 30#, connector
sleeves and brass swivels are found in most fishing
supply stores. Dubro clevises and fittings are sold in
local Hobby Bench and other stores. Woven Spectra line is
said to be sold in the fishing section of Walmart and
other stores up to 50#. I found it difficult to get and
bought on-line from the excellent
Hang-em-high kite supply store www.citystar.com/hang-em-high, who also supply carbon
fiber/epoxy tube for spars etc. Where Spectra is just not
obtainable Dacron polyester braided line is the next
best.
I propose
that the rules allow use of commercially available or
home-made materials, and fittings for the stays and
shrouds provided they merely perform the kit intentions
of security and lengthwise adjustment.
2. The
outhaul and trim adjustment for both jib and main is
clumsy and hard to repeat. The cam cleats to secure the
outhauls tend to foul the sheet lines. Dennis
Desprois (Walrus Sails, Scottsdale) showed me a neat way
to fix these problems by installing a pair of sliding
bowsies, one each side, on the fore end of the jib club
and boom (SD2, 3 & 4). These comprise a piece
of Spectra 200# line and two plastic rings cut off a tube
(1 cm o.d, 2 mm wall, Pex plumbing pipe will work). Two
holes are drilled horizontally through the spar roughly 6
cm apart (more if you need more travel). The rings are
converted to bowsies by drilling three holes in the rim
at, say 2, 4 and 8 oclock. The line is threaded
through, under and along the spar incorporating one
bowsie on each side using the 2 & 4 oclock
holes, leaving the 8-holes facing aft and the line is
tied off under the spar. This allows either bowsie to
slide fore and aft along the spar. The Spectra 200# line
from the sail clew is led through the hole at the aft end
of the spar and through the 8-hole in the bowsie. After
finding a suitable mid point position a knot is tied
inside the plastic ring to secure the line and the end
burned off.
For the main and
jib sheets I attach Spectra 200# by safety pin to the
sail winch arm and lead through the deck opening and
around the pulley and terminate in a small loop just
ahead of the pulley with the winch in close hauled
position (SD3). I run Spectra 50#
lines from the loop for jib and main sheets. For main
sheet I run the line through the ring and bridle from the
kit, a small split ring (~1 cm) attached to the plastic
eye on the underside of the boom and terminate with a kit
safety pin. The safety pin attaches to another split ring
on the end of Spectra 200# line run through the 8-hole of
the main trim bowsie, adjusted and tied off as for the
outhaul. The jib sheet is run forward through deck eyes
as in the kit, up through a split ring attached to the
plastic eye on the club and terminated in a safety pin.
This is then attached to the jib trim bowsie as for the
main sheet (SD4).
These
arrangements may have another slight side benefit, at
least as far as the jib is concerned. By removing the
weight of the cleat from the aft end of the club and
replacing it with bowsie weight forward of the pivot it
may assist rotation of the jib in light air.
I propose that the rules allow
use of alternative materials and fittings, as well as
location of attachment points to jib and boom, for jib
and main sheet and outhaul control provided they merely
perform the kit intended functions.
3. The jib club
and main boom in the kit are too short to allow proper
sail adjustment. You will note I have incorporated
jib and boom extensions which other skippers have also
found useful. For the main boom, one of our Sun City
skippers fabricated replacement end pieces from plastic
strips, which fit into the end of the aluminum section,
and are secured by a screw from underneath the spar (SD3). By leaving the screw
head protruding slightly it acts as a stop to prevent the
loop, which limits vertical travel of the sail clew, from
sliding too far aft. This allows the outhaul line to
exert aftward pull on the clew while the vertical travel
is held fairly constant.
For the jib I
simply replaced the plastic kit piece with a piece of ¼
inch wood dowell secured again with a screw from
underneath the spar (SD4). This provides a
similar arrangement for the jib and, in addition, allows
a topping lift (leach line) to be attached at the aft end
of the club and run, complete with bowsie, up to the
forestay attachment point on the mast without fouling the
sail leach (SD1 & 5). While the kit clearly
does not provide a topping lift, the ability to adjust
twist to match the main sail helps get the most out of
the boat especially in light air.
I would like
to see the rules allow for jib and boom extension. Maybe
we could persuade KYOSHO to offer longer aluminum
sections either as an after market kit or to modify the
regular kit sold?
4. In
the kit the sail tack is fixed at a constant distance
above the boom. You will note that while I have left
the attachment for the head of the sail as in the kit, I
have added a cam cleat on the mast above the boom which
is used to secure the downhaul from the sail tack after
looping under the gooseneck (SD3 & 4). This arrangement
allows me, within a small range, to make adjustments in
luff tension with or without changes in sail twist
without adjusting the vang. Essentially I am moving the
sail vertically at the luff while leaving the clew at a
fixed location. Does this make sense?
It is not a
big deal but I would like to see the rules allow for
adjustment of the main downhaul.
5. Sails,
kit or after market and luff attachment systems.
Having sailed quite successfully with the kit sails, I
bought a suit of paneled Mylar sails (kit dimensions)
from Dennis Desprois (Walrus Sails). The main reasons
were that the kit sails came creased and never looked
good, I wanted to see what effect sails with built in
camber had versus the flat paneled kit sails and Dennis
just plain makes nice looking and performing sails. After
about six months of sailing with each type my
observations are that the system for attachment of the
sail luff to the forestay and main spar respectively have
a greater impact on sail performance than sail type,
especially in light air.
For the jib the
Steelon forestay is run through seven small pieces of
plastic tube attached to the sail luff with adhesive tape
(SD1, 2 & 5). I found that the small
red plastic tube supplied with each can of WD40 works
just fine! Luff tension is maintained and adjusted by
anchoring the tack by a line through the second hole in
the kit piece supplied and knotted below the spar, while
the head is secured to the jib attachment point with
its own separate line and adjustment bowsie. This
allows freedom of rotation and separate forestay and jib
luff tension adjustments. This just plain works better
then the kit system!
I propose
that the rules allow use of after market sails using the
same dimensions as the kit and alternative attachments of
jib to forestay and separate forestay and jib tension
adjustment.
For the main it
gets a bit more complicated. When I first saw the
aluminum section spar with bolt rope tunnel in back it
reminded me of the DN iceboat system. However in the DN
the spar can rotate on a ball at its base and is only
supported at one point about ¾ of the way up. In this
way it forms an effective leading edge for the airfoil
with mast bend and rotation key factors in sail
performance. The Seawinds fixed spar means that the
sail folds around the aft edge of the spar especially
when it is all the way out and can produce some nasty
looking creases which are difficult to trim out. When the
kit sail was replaced with a stiffer Mylar paneled sail,
with pieces of plastic tube fixed on the luff as for the
jib and running inside the bolt rope tunnel, this effect
was amplified by a resistance to change shape, which
hindered coming about in light air.
In one
modification I stabilized the spar at the joint with
heavier gauge and vertically longer aluminum spreaders
and eliminated the lower shroud. However I had to
eliminate this option as the spar was too prone to fore
and aft bend.
Others, and I,
have found that conversion to simple loops of line
(Spectra 50#) for attachment of the luff to the spar
provides an effective system which performs better in
light air (SD5). In my version I have
kept the leading edge of the luff as close behind the
spar as possible while others have adopted a gap of about
1/8 inch, but in either version the key is to allow
easier sail rotation about the spar.
All of the above
suggests there is no reason for the aluminum section spar
provided by the kit, a tubular section would perform as
well or better which leads on to substitution by a carbon
fiber/epoxy tubular spar.
One of our
skippers has installed a carbon fiber/epoxy tube mast,
eliminated the lower shroud and modified the gooseneck
fittings and mast crane to attach to the tubular spar.
While it is not clear that this confers any significant
performance advantage my own view is that this is getting
away from the one-design philosophy and into workshop
mods.
I would be
happy with freedom to attach the main sail with loops of
line and leave the kit spar, shrouds and fittings in
place?
6. Deck
fittings and scale detail. As you can see I have
installed per kit instructions all the deck fittings. I
know of no skipper who has had any problem with location
or function of any of the stay or shroud attachment
fittings. One or two skippers have replaced the ring and
bridle system for the main sheet by a fixed post and loop
borrowed from a Northwind kit. Although it performs the
same function it seems to me to diverge unnecessarily
from the one-design. There is no doubt that from time to
time skippers get their sheet lines caught up in one of
the deck fittings, winches or wheels and many have
removed or never installed them.
I propose
that only kit-supplied fittings can be attached to the
deck in the locations indicated. Items may be omitted but
not substituted (whats the harm if there is a
minimum weight?).
One or two
skippers have installed charging jacks or on/off switches
set into the deck or a magnetically operated reed switch
fixed to the underside of the deck. I see no problem
with these, as they do not affect boat performance.
7. What
to do with the antenna wire? I have stayed with the
kit instruction and just let the antenna wire drape into
the bow below decks. Several skippers seem convinced that
it is essential for the antenna wire to protrude above
the deck and lead the wire through a grommet (flexible
plastic tube) let into the deck and attach the end of the
wire to the mast or even hook on to the spreader. I was
about to try it myself when, in the middle of a regatta,
I experienced a lot of radio interference. I solved the
problem by whipping out the receiver and changing
crystals to a different frequency. Imagine trying to do
that in a hurry with the antenna wire firmly anchored
above decks! I have never experienced any problem
traceable to the antenna wire being below decks. One neat
idea I saw somewhere is to run a line of CA glue along
one side of a plastic drinking straw and stick it to the
right underside of the deck towards the bow. Then poke
the antenna wire down the straw. This has the merit of
keeping the antenna above the waterline and out of any
bilge water without hindering removal of the receiver. I
dont think the rules need to dictate the location
of the antenna.
7. Gooseneck
swivel and vang. When installed I found the ball
joint swivel on the gooseneck to be stiff to operate,
hindering boom rotation in light air. I found a temporary
fix by loosening the securing screw, however, if not
watched closely it will work loose or come out
altogether. Here is a way to free it up. Remove the
securing screw leaving the boom with ball and socket
attachment on the end. Run a threaded rod or bolt through
the ball and secure it top and bottom with nuts. Put the
rod or bolt in the chuck of a drill, put paste rubbing
compound over the exposed portion of the ball and spin
the ball in the socket with the drill while oscillating
the ball and socket joint. Repeat with more rubbing
compound and flush waste out with WD40 until satisfied
with the freedom of rotation.
Adjustment of
the vang itself is a bit tedious requiring snapping off
the top ball joint and screwing the end piece(s) to
adjust the length and re-attaching the ball and socket. A
turnbuckle type adjustment would be nice but I guess I
can live with what the kit provides.
I hope this
note will help some skippers avoid having to
reinvent the wheel and help all get the most
satisfaction out of sailing our Seawinds. I welcome all
comments and alternative suggestions.
| Part 1 | Photos |
|